Shetland
2013 · 94% matchRecommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8).
Mystery Island
Mystery
London Police psychiatrist Dr. Emilia Priestly needs to take a relaxing break from her stressful job, so her wealthy friend invites her to Mystery Island, an immersive murder-mystery-themed resort hosting a special retreat for the original investors. As the mystery game begins, tragedy strikes when the resort's reclusive founder is murdered. Emilia "partners" with local detective Jason Trent to investigate.
- Status
- Running
- Language
- English
- Premiered
- September 29, 2023
If you liked Mystery Island, try these
Paradise Lost
2020 · 93% matchRecommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8), hidden gem.
Prime Suspect
1991 · 93% matchRecommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8).
Flower Shop Mystery
2016 · 92% matchRecommended for similar Mystery profile, hidden gem, also on Hallmark Mystery.
Black Snow
2023 · 91% matchRecommended for similar Mystery profile.
Dexter: Resurrection
2025 · 91% matchRecommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8.5).
Mare of Easttown
2021 · 91% matchRecommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8).
Ripper Street
2012 · 90% matchRecommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8.1), hidden gem.
A Martha's Vineyard Mystery
2020 · 90% matchRecommended for similar Mystery profile, also on Hallmark Mystery.
Picture Perfect Mysteries
2019 · 90% matchRecommended for similar Mystery profile, also on Hallmark Mystery.
Series Similar to Mystery Island
If you enjoyed Mystery Island, these series share similar themes, tone, and quality. Each recommendation is scored on genre overlap, tonal match, and critical acclaim.
Recommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8).
The dark side of one of the most beautiful places on earth. Uncovering secrets and lies from the past.
Recommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8), hidden gem.
Paradise Lost is about a psychiatrist who moves with her family from California to her husband's hometown in Mississippi only to uncover shameful secrets that irrevocably change the lives of everyone involved.
Recommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8).
This tense, uncompromising drama starring the Oscar®-winning actress Helen Mirren and from the distinguished dramatist and novelist Lynda La Plante, has been critically acclaimed on both sides of the Atlantic and has won a total of 14 international awards including BAFTAs for 'Drama Serial' and 'TV Actress'.
Recommended for similar Mystery profile, hidden gem, also on Hallmark Mystery.
"Flower Shop Mystery: Mum's the Word" is the 1st made for TV movie in Hallmark Channel's latest mystery movie franchise. Flower Shop Mystery is based on the novel by Kate Collins. Abby Knight, a former lawyer turned flower shop owner, is starting over after the death of her husband with the support of her father and her daughter, who recently left for college. Life is good in the peaceful town of New Chapel, but when an SUV rams her prized vintage car, she's determined to track down the driver. She begrudgingly accepts the help of a new neighbor, the handsome and charming ex-Marine Marco Salvare. But their budding relationship is threatened when an acquaintance is murdered and Abby's good friend is the prime suspect -- and it all links back to the hit and run. Caught up in a tangle of menacing phone calls, police corruption and murderous road rage, Abby must work against the clock to find the killer or the next flower arrangement might be for her own funeral.
Recommended for similar Mystery profile.
In 1994, seventeen-year-old Isabel Baker was murdered. The crime shocked the small town of Ashford and devastated Isabel's Australian South Sea Islander community. The case was never solved, the killer never found. But in 2019, the opening of a time capsule unearths a secret that puts cold-case Detective James Cormack on the trail of the killer.
Recommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8.5).
Dexter Morgan awakens from a coma and sets out for New York City, determined to find Harrison and make things right. But when Miami Metro's Angel Batista arrives with questions, Dexter realizes his past is catching up to him fast.
Recommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8).
Mare of Easttown follows a small-town Pennsylvania detective who investigates a local murder at a time when her own life is crumbling around her.
Recommended for similar Mystery profile, highly rated (8.1), hidden gem.
The Whitechapel police fight to bring law to the lawless in the wake of Jack the Ripper's reign of terror.
Recommended for similar Mystery profile, also on Hallmark Mystery.
After being injured and facing loss in the line of duty, retired Boston Police Detective Jeff Jackson returns to a quiet life of fishing, living in his late father's home on Martha's Vineyard. When a mysterious visitor to the island turns up dead, Jeff is reluctantly recruited to help in the investigation by the local police chief, a family friend.
Recommended for similar Mystery profile, also on Hallmark Mystery.
A photographer ends up helping the local police detective solve mysteries.